Why we can't record our TV shows (was: In case you have not seen it.....Linux Media Center)

[Seth Cohn]

>   *** DO NOT DISCUSS ILLEGAL ACTIVITIES ON THIS LIST. ****

I understand your point, and will comply with your wishes, despite my
_opinion_ that it's not illegal in the first place.

> pissing match with the MPAA.

Since we were talking television and not ever movies, the MPAA isn't
an issue, but again, I know what you meant here.  RIAA, MPAA,
Information Mafia, it's all the same thing.

> play whenever you like.  In particular, online discussion forums such
> as this one are *not* Common Carriers.  Go ask a lawyer.

googling for "discussion forum liability common carrier" finds lots of
discussion about the merits of this on both sides.  Those interested
can read for themselves.

Rather scary how a mere discussion of the legalities elicts such a
furor,  another chilling effect illustrated... when you can't discuss
the issues (and use illustrations such as links of the sort of things
that are under fire), what's left but to cave in and give up?

Seth